HAIG    REPORT:    GoTo [on this page] HaigReport's Menu Of Themes of Menus for our thousands of pages
TIPS for
Navigating HaigReport:  If you arrived at this page, referred from a Search Engine such as Google et al, your URL link will NOT have an #Anchor/Marker to take you to the relevant spot on this page.  In that case, we do recommend that you view our "Latest HaigReport Promotions" of recent additions to our websites, by Clicking Here.  It will open in a new Browser window. 

If
you Click Here, you will be taken, usually, to the specific Unique Content on this page, for which you were most likely seeking.  However, if you Click Here, you will be taken to the Top of the HaigReport Header, below on this page. 

However, if you have arrived at this page from another of our Website pages, your link will usually have an #Anchor, also called a marker, which will take you to the intended specific spot on the page where that marker is positioned.  In fact, it will probably take you there prior to your reading this.  Moving to that Anchor is the final step in the loading of this page.

 HAIG     REPORT:   Is now on  twitter  [from 2nd June, 2013]  link to us HERE on twitter     See our Twitter Strategy    

 HAIG    REPORT:  SEE: Russell Mathews' COMMENTARY:    Russell Mathews' [BCom BSc LLB & BA] current TOPICAL commentary on GOVERNMENT, politics & business     Press to READ       Press for MENU   

 HAIG    REPORT:    WANTED:
Healthy female "dog" to breed with Parson Russell Terrier, to produce ASSISTANCE DOGS.   Rochedale South QLD 4123
I wish to breed from my Parson Russell Terrier. He is a trained assistance dog. He has a wonderful nature. The breed of his mate could be varied or a cross; eg Parson Russell Terrier, Jack Russell Terrier, Beagle, Bull Terrier, Bull mastiff, Staffy, and/or Fox Terrier plus many others. She does not need to be "pedigreed". I am very protective of my dogs. She will become very valuable to me and become one of my assistance "dogs". If we can assist each other, please contact me on my contact form, including your email address and your landline phone number so I can phone you to discuss. 

Because I am disabled and have an LLB [so therefore understand the Law surrounding disabilities and assistance dogs] I am now branching out to providing Assistance dogs to disabled persons [even if disabled in only a minor way and so not even realizing it]. This is not a business proposition but rather just a very necessary service I can offer to the community.
Many people have a disability and do not realize their ailment or "problem" is by law, the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) [DDA], classified as a "disability". This is especially so for people getting on in years, and who have a dog, and are maybe moving to accommodation where they are told they cannot take their dog. In a majority of cases, those people cannot be legally forced to surrender their animal/dog.
I will be assisting those person who already have dogs, but are being forced, unlawfully, to dispose of them because maybe they are moving accommodation. I can train your existing dogs to be assistance dogs and provide the documentation as required by the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) [DDA]. I do not intend to charge for this, but just maybe cover some marginal costs.

    View the Latest    HAIG     REPORT Promotions:  in this Scrolling Window, or OPEN in new browser:     

 Click here  to Learn how your Personalized Alert Notice [IMMEDIATELY ABOVE] is prepared by our HAIG Unique Visitor Algorithm: [HUVA] or  Click here  to see your UNIQUE Personalized Alert Notice in a new Browser Window.


 Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Lies & Dishonesty in Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB:


My logo, my TRADEMARK, is the MRI of my skull, showing gross assymetry,aka DEFORMITY = ugliness and target of bullies. The HAIG REPORT: the EVIDENCE My logo, my TRADEMARK, is the MRI of my skull, showing gross assymetry,aka DEFORMITY = ugliness and target of bullies.

   It is Our legal, social and moral DUTY to EXPOSE CRIME, FRAUD & CORRUPTION plus Lying and Hypocrisy in Public Life, Including Judges & magistrates 
 

Fraud, Corruption & attempted  MURDER 
covered-up by Queensland police, EXPOSED 

header: Queensland Court of Appeal on Trial

CourtOfAppealOnTrialJusticeMargaretAMcMurdoACPresidentQueenslandCourtofAppeal  Queensland Court of Appeal on Trial CourtOfAppealOnTrialJusticeMargaretAMcMurdoACPresidentQueenslandCourtofAppeal

commonheader.php

Reg. Office: 254 Hawken Drive, St Lucia, Qld. 4067, Australia.  
Editor-in-Chief:  Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA      EMAIL us anytime:  Please Please make a donation using BPay.  using  Please make a donation using BPay. 

considerevidence.php

Consider the evidence! Please Please make a donation using BPay.  using  Please make a donation using BPay.  

/CodingPHP/includedSeeContentPageFileNameURL.php

  Click here to GoTo Detail:=> Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Lies & Dishonesty in Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB

../Corrupt Police& Magistrates Menu.php An example of a CASCADING Drop Down Menu.

MENU: Rantala-Gate: Corrupt Police & Magistrates Mafia.

CDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.php

See: the Menu: for  Latest Update: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!

Follow @HaigReport
??   ??   ???? Tweet  
Share on Facebook Share on Facebook  
http://HaigReport.com/includedSeeTodaysHotTopics.php

See: Today's HAIG HOT_TOPICS  => Click HERE <= 

/CodingPHP/includedSeeContentPageFileNameURL.php

  Click here to GoTo Detail:=> Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Lies & Dishonesty in Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB

See: the Menu: for  Latest Update: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!

Follow @HaigReport
??   ??   ???? Tweet  
Share on Facebook Share on Facebook  
http://HaigReport.com/includedSeeTodaysHotTopics.php

See: Today's HAIG HOT_TOPICS  => Click HERE <= 

 Content: Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Lies & Dishonesty in Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB

../Corrupt Police& Magistrates Menu.php An example of a CASCADING Drop Down Menu.

MENU: Rantala-Gate: Corrupt Police & Magistrates Mafia.

CDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.php

See: the Menu: for  Latest Update: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!

Follow @HaigReport
??   ??   ???? Tweet  
Share on Facebook Share on Facebook  
OUTLINE OF SUBMISSIONS


IN THE COURT OF APPEAL


SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND



CA NUMBER 201 of 2011



Appellant: RUSSELL GORDON HAIG MATHEWS



Respondent: COMMISSIONER OF POLICE



OUTLINE OF SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENT


1. Dates of Offences:

(i) between 26 July 2008 and 18 July 2009

(ii) between 21 August 2006 and 18 July 2009

(iii) between 22 February 2007 and 18 July 2009

(iv) between 12 June 2009 and 18 July 2009


2. Nature of Offences:

Using a carriage service to menace, harass or cause offence x 4

Commonwealth Criminal Code s.474.17


3. Court and Judicial Officer:

1. Brisbane Magistrates Court, Mr P Kluck (at first instance)

2. Brisbane District Court, O’Brien DCJA (s.222 Justices Act Appeal)


4. Date of Order:

1. 24 September 2010

2. 21 June 2011


5. Nature of Order:

Referral of proceedings to the District Court for determination of fitness to be tried: Crimes Act 1914 s.20B(1).


6. Age and date of birth of offender:

61 years, born 21 March 1950


7. Circumstances of the matter in relation to which the appeal is brought:


7.1 Crimes Act 1914 Division 6 – Unfitness to be Tried

7.1.1 s.20B(1) makes provision for the referral by a magistrate of committal proceedings to the court to which the person would be committed for trial, if in the course of the committal the question of the person’s fitness for trial is raised by the person or by the prosecution. Where the question of fitness for trial is raised the referral is mandatory.


7.2 Proceedings before the Magistrates Court

7.2.1 The appellant was charged with the subject offences by a constable of Queensland police on 28 August 2009. The charges were further mentioned on 14 September 2009 and 2 November 2009. On both occasions the defendant appeared in person, unrepresented.


7.2.2 On 25 January 2010, the charges were again mentioned in the Magistrates Court at Brisbane. The appellant did not personally attend but was represented by counsel from Newcastle, a Mr Higgins, who appeared by telephone. At this mention the charges were adjourned for further mention in order for the defence to obtain “detailed reports from a psychiatrist and a psychologist”. (Record p.26 l.10)


7.2.3 At the next mention of the charges, on 15 March 2010, the appellant appeared in person, unrepresented. No psychiatric or psychological reports were tendered. At this mention the appellant tendered a written application (Supp. Record p.1) to dismiss the charges (Record p.37 l.29-47). In this written application and in oral submissions to the Magistrate, the appellant indicated that he had estimated that the hearing to dismiss the charges would take 40 hours. (Record p.34 l.35, Supp Record p.3). Consequently the matter was listed for hearing for 6 days commencing on 24 June 2010.


7.2.4 During the committal review on 9 June 2010, the Magistrate ruled, with respect to the application to dismiss the charges (Supp. Record p.1), that he had no power to make such an order; nor did the he have power to stay the proceedings as an abuse of process. (Record p.77 l.23-45). In support of his decision to refuse the application to dismiss the charges, the Magistrate cited Higgins v. Comans [2005] QCA 234 and further explained his reasons (Record p.81 l.29 to p.82 l.40).


7.2.5 Further during the committal review on 9 June 2010, in view of the appellant’s stated disabilities, the appellant was granted permission to have a camera as well as his two assistance dogs present in court with him during the committal. (Record p.57 l.19-58; p.58 l.11-12; p.60 l. 15-17; p.68 l.21; p.69 l.55)


7.2.6 The committal proceeding commenced before the Magistrate on 24 June 2010. The appellant was unrepresented.


7.2.7 The appellant attended the proceeding for the first three days and cross examined witnesses. On Day 4 (29 June 2010) the appellant advised the Court by e-mail that he would not be appearing as he would be consulting his psychiatrist. The appellant did not thereafter attend court in person. Eight review mentions were held before the Magistrate between 29 June 2010 and 24 September 2010 to consider the further conduct of the matter. The appellant communicated with the Court by e-mail on numerous of those occasions. The broad effect of his e-mails was that a brain injury affected his ability to concentrate and question witnesses verbally in the court environment. He proposed that his “special needs” be accommodated by the Magistrate’s allowing cross-examination by e-mail without his physical attendance.


7.2.8 On 15 September 2010, despite Crown submissions to the contrary, (Record p 450 l.50 to p.456 l.19) the Magistrate ruled that the appellant had, by his conduct, raised the issue of his fitness for trial (Record p.459 l.42-55). The order of referral was formally made on 24 September 2010. (Record p.471 l.20-24)


7.2.9 The extracts from the transcript of 15 September 2010 relevant to the Magistrate’s conclusion that the question of the appellant’s fitness to be tried had been raised were set out in the respondent’s outline in the s.222 Appeal and appear at Record p.656. [Page reference 12-6 of the transcript referred to in the outline equates to Record p.454]


7.3 Proceedings before the District Court

7.3.1 On 16 May 2011, the appellant appeared by telephone in the District Court at Brisbane and argued his appeal “in real time”, adding verbal submissions to his written outline and answering his Honour’s questions as required. (Record p.612 to 635)


8. Matters relied on by the Respondent


8.1 Application of s.222 of the Justices Act 1886 (Qld) – (“the Act”):

8.1.1 Section 222(1) of the Act provides:

If a person feels aggrieved as complainant, defendant or otherwise by an order made by justices or a justice in a summary way on a complaint for an offence or breach of duty, the person may appeal within 1 month after the date of the order to a District Court judge.”


8.1.2 “Order” is defined in s.4 of the Act to include:

...any order, adjudication, grant or refusal of any application, and any determination of whatsoever kind made by a Magistrates Court, and any refusal by a Magistrates Court to hear and determine any complaint or to entertain any application made to it ...”


8.1.3 The words “an order ... on a complaint” in s.222(1) have repeatedly been held to refer only to those orders that finally dispose of the complaint.


        1. Schneider v Curtis [1967] Qd R 300 held that no appeal lies against the rejection of a no case submission in a summary prosecution. Gibbs J held, at 304-5:

The section does not give a right of appeal from any order made in proceedings commenced by a complaint but only from “an order made upon a complaint.” These words ... in my opinion refer to an order disposing of the complaint itself and do not include an order upon an application made during the course of proceedings instituted by the complaint...”


8.1.3.2 Owen v Canavan & anor, CA 199 of 1994, 4 August 1995 held, affirming Schneider v Curtis, that no appeal lies against an order of a magistrate refusing to transfer summary proceedings from Brisbane to Gympie.


8.1.3.3 In Paulger v Hall [2003] 2 Qd R 294, Holmes J (with whom McMurdo P and Mackenzie J agreed), said at [26]:

Schneider v Curtis is authority for the proposition that no appeal lies under s222 from a ruling made on an incidental application during the hearing of the complaint; the right of appeal is given only from "any order made ... upon a complaint", and those words refer to an order "disposing of the complaint itself"...


8.1.3.4 Coulter v Ryan [2007] 2 Qd R 302 held, by majority, that no appeal lies against a refusal to award costs on an interlocutory (adjournment) application and reiterated the correctness of Schneider v Curtis.


8.1.4 An order under Crimes Act s.20B(1) does not finally dispose of the complaint. It “refers” the committal proceedings to the court to which the charges might be committed. The proceedings themselves remain on foot pending the determination of the issue of fitness to be tried, and may be referred back to the Magistrate should the person be adjudged fit for trial.


8.1.5 Since no final determination of the complaint had been made, an appeal pursuant to s.222 of the Act was not open. Accordingly, the decision of O’Brien DCJA to dismiss the appeal was correct.


8.2 Referral pursuant to s.20B of the Crimes Act

8.2.1 If the decision to refer the proceedings pursuant to Crimes Act s.20B(1) was held to be open to appeal under s.222 of the Act, and leave to appeal is granted pursuant to District Court Act s.118(3), this appeal should be allowed but only to the extent that the proceedings be remitted to the Magistrate for the continuation of the committal hearing.

8.2.2 Though the referral pursuant to s.20B of the Crimes Act is mandatory if the “question” of the appellant’s fitness to be tried is “raised”, the “question” must be a “real and substantial question”.

8.2.3 In R v Ogawa [2009] QCA 307 at [100], Keane JA quoted a number of authorities which provide guidance on the issue of whether the “real question” of fitness to be tried as been “raised”


8.2.4 In particular, in Kesavarajah v R (1994) 181 CLR 230 at 245, Mason CJ, Toohey & Gaudron JJ stated:

Sometimes the test has been stated in terms of whether there is a reason to doubt the accused’s fitness to stand trial (Gibbons [1947] 1 DLR 45 at 49). However, the judge should leave the issue to be tried by the jury unless no reasonable jury, properly instructed, could find that the accused was not fit to be tried”


8.2.5 In view of the objective facts in this case, no jury properly instructed could find the appellant unfit to be tried. As O’Brien DCJA observed (Record p.662 para 8):

The appellant had cross examined witnesses over the first three days of the hearing and had asked questions designed to establish what he saw as a possible defence to the charges. Prosecuting counsel had submitted that the medical evidence was scant and that the appellant’s conduct was not such as to raise any issue of fitness for trial. In my view, it would have been clearly open to the Magistrate to continue with the committal hearing.”


8.3 Refusal to strike out the charges prior to or during the committal

8.3.1 It is settled law that a magistrate, when conducting a committal hearing, does not have power to stay the proceedings as an abuse of process.


8.3.2 The powers of a magistrate when conducting a committal hearing are circumscribed by s.108 of the Act. Upon all the evidence being lead, the magistrate has power to do only one of two things; as Keane JA in Higgins v. Comans [2005] QCA 234 observed at [26] - [27]:

If there is sufficient evidence then the accused must be committed for trial, while if there is not sufficient evidence then the accused must be discharged. As with the legislation that the High Court was considering in Grassby:

the scheme of that section, far from requiring the implication of a general power to stay proceedings, is such as to impose an obligation upon the magistrate to dispose of the information which brings the defendant before him by discharging the defendant as to it or by committing him for trial.

in my opinion, the existence of … a power [to stay proceedings] is impliedly precluded by a statutory scheme which requires that a magistrate reach one of only two end points.


8.3.3 His Honour further stated at [28]:

it is impossible to imply a power of the type contended for by the appellant. This was precisely the consideration that led Dawson J to conclude in Grassby that:

There is no room in the face of these statutory obligations, couched as they are in mandatory terms, for the implication of a discretionary power to terminate the proceedings in a manner other than that provided. Nor is this surprising. True it is that a person committed for trial is exposed to trial in a way in which he would otherwise not be, but the ultimate determination whether he does in fact stand trial does not rest with the magistrate. The power to order a stay where there is an abuse of the process of the trial court is not to be found in the committing magistrate and the considerations which would guide the exercise of that power have little relevance to the function which the magistrate is required to perform.


8.3.4 The Magistrate was therefore correct on 9 June 2010 in refusing the application to strike out the charges. (Record p.77 l.23-45) and (Record p.81 l.29 to p.82 l.40). Similarly O’Brien DCJA was correct in holding (Record p.662 para 7):

It is clear in my view that the power to stay on the grounds of an abuse of process is one that may only be exercised following the completion of the committal proceedings, and then, … only by the Court to which the defendant is committed”


8.4 Due Process

8.4.1 It can be inferred from the nature of the matters raised by the Magistrate at the committal review on 9 June 2010 that the appellant had, in writing, sought permission from the Chief Magistrate to allow him to have his assistance dogs (Record p.58 l.8-13) and a camera (Record p.56 l.1 et seq) in court with him during the committal. Despite ample opportunity to do so, no further “special measures” were sought either in the appellant’s correspondence or in oral submissions. Both requests were granted.

8.4.2 At the mention on 15 March 2010, when the matter was listed for hearing the appellant did not express any apprehension towards the suggestion that he attend court on 6 consecutive sitting days. (Record p.35 l.55 to p.36 l.28).


8.4.3 For the three days upon which the committal proceeded, the appellant appeared in person and cross examined five witnesses. On the afternoon of the first day the proceedings concluded early (3.20pm) due to the appellant expressing his fatigue (Record p.174 l.10-19 and p.182 l.5-13) and did not resume until 11.00am the next day (Record p.177 l.25).


8.4.4 On the afternoon of the second day, the proceedings were adjourned for the day when the appellant stated that his mind had gone blank in respect of the further questions he wished to ask the police case officer. (Record p.249 l.39-53)

8.4.5 Extra breaks were taken throughout the hearing to allow the appellant to compose himself and attend to the needs of his assistance dogs. As observed by the Magistrate at a subsequent mention on 15 September 2010 (Record p.456 l.35-44)


The Court has allowed Mr Mathews regular breaks throughout the proceedings, thus far, over and above what is normal. … He's allowed to have his assistance dogs in Court. … something which is not normally done.


8.4.6 On the afternoon of the third day, the appellant cross examined Sgt Rantala (Record p.381 – 399), a person towards whom, it can be inferred, the appellant bears a significant degree of ill-will. When court adjourned for the day at about “normal” time, the appellant gave no indication to the Magistrate that he was so fatigued as to be unable to proceed further with the hearing. (Record p.399 l.25 – p.400 l.20). On the contrary, he appeared eager to continue.


8.4.7 The Record shows that the hearing was progressing. That progress was, at times, slower than at others, due to the effects of the appellant’s condition and the steps the Court took to accommodate them. Nonetheless, the Record reveals that in all respects the hearing was conducted in accordance with the provisions of the Act.


8.4.8 It is not for a defendant to dictate the way in which a committal hearing is to proceed.


8.4.8.1 Section 104(1) of the Act (as it stood in June 2010), which is mandatory in its terms, states:

The examination of witnesses in relation to an indictable offence—

(a) may be conducted by a single justice;

(b) subject to the provisions of section 40, shall be conducted in the presence and hearing of the defendant, if the defendant is required to be present, and of the defendant’s lawyer (if any).


8.4.8.2 In R v. Ogawa [2009] QCA 307, the Court considered the application of s.617 of the Qld Criminal Code, the principles relevant to which, it is submitted, are equally applicable to s.104 of the Act. Keane JA, with whom Chesterman JA and Jones J agreed, observed at [189-190] that the DPP’s argument in the following terms “must be accepted”:


The DPP’s argument continues:

It is not for an accused person in a criminal trial to choose whether she wants to participate in the proceedings. Nor is it for them to dictate the course of the proceedings. Section 617(1) of the Criminal Code (Qld) is in mandatory terms (See R v TQ [2007] QCA 255). … The effect of the ground is that the Appellant was provoked into behaving as she did. The learned trial judge’s proper conduct of the trial cannot be used as a basis to justify the Appellant’s … misbehaviour.


8.4.8.3 The appellant’s assertions that he is unable to “debate in real time” should be viewed with suspicion because of the number of times he has appeared as an unrepresented litigant/party. Further, in the case of Tierney v. Commissioner of Police [2011] QCA 293, on 18 October 2011, the appellant unsuccessfully sought leave to appear on behalf of Mr Tierney. In the Court’s unanimous ex tempore judgment dismissing the appellant’s applications the President observed at [3]:


Mr Mathews has been declared a vexatious litigant and is prevented from instituting proceedings in any court in relation to the Brisbane City Council: see Brisbane City Council v Russell Gordon Haig Mathews [2006] QSC 25. Mr Mathews has previously appeared on his own behalf in many hearings including R v Mathews [1992] QCA 462, [1995] QCA 336 and [2010] QCA 196; Mathews v Smith [1997] QCA 365; Mathews v Telstra Corporation Ltd [1998] QCA 407; Russell Mathews v Rev Canon Professor Dr John Morgan & Ors [2006] QCA 143; and Mathews v Cabrera [2010] QCA 300.


8.4.9 The Magistrates reasons (below) for conducting the hearing in the manner which he did cannot, in all the circumstances (above), amount to a failure to accord the appellant due process such that the proceedings were rendered a nullity and therefore “finally determined”.


But as I understand it, he's asking the Court to allow him to proceed in what I would think would be an unworkable and unmanageable way for an adversarial environment … that a committal proceeding is to be able to cross-examine witnesses. And importantly, I think, even if I were to consider what he's proposing, what I think he's proposing to cross-examine by e-mail, I think there's a real risk that I wouldn’t be allowing him to do justice to himself. In other words, he wouldn’t get a fair committal. (Record p.454 l.57 – p.455 l.12)


9. Orders Sought:

9.1 That leave to appeal should be refused

9.2 If leave to appeal is granted, that save for any order which the Court might make consistent with paragraph 8.2.1 hereof, the appeal be dismissed.






S R Hunter

Counsel for the Respondent

9 November 2011


Outline of Respondent’s Submissions Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions

Level 19, 15 Adelaide Street, Brisbane Q 4000

Filed on behalf of the Respondent Phn: (07) 3224-9444

Fax: (07) 3224-9473

Ref: Shane Hunter

Email: CommDPP.Brisbane@cdpp.gov.au



 Menu:  Latest Update: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!

PHPincludesCourtOfAppealOnTrial/includedMenuCourtOfAppealOnTrial.php

Menu:  Latest Update: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!!!


  1. Don Dale Commissioner Margaret White Judicial Corruption Connection:
  2. Affidavit for Court of Appeal: Why CDCJ Patsy Mary Wolfe Unfit to be a Judge due Judicial Fraud when barrister:
  3. Appeal to Court of Appeal CDCJ Patsy Wolfe Deny Refuse Recuse Apprehended Bias Form27:
  4. Appeal to Court of Appeal CDCJ Patsy Wolfe Deny Refuse Recuse Apprehended Bias Form29:
  5. Appeal to Court of Appeal CDCJ Patsy Wolfe Deny Refuse Recuse Apprehended Bias Form38 Adduce Evidence:
  6. Appeal to Court of Appeal CDCJ Patsy Wolfe Deny Refuse Recuse Apprehended Bias Affidavit Adduce Evidence:
  7. Appeal to Court of Appeal DCJA Kerry O'Brien Deny Qualified Privilege Form27:
  8. Appeal to Court of Appeal DCJA Kerry O'Brien Unlawful Order Disability Discrimination Apprehended Bias Form27:
  9. Appeal to Court of Appeal DCJA Kerry O'Brien Unlawful Order Disability Discrimination Apprehended Bias Form29:
  10. Appeal to Court of Appeal DCJ Spurious Michael Shanahan Refuse Recuse Apprehended Bias Form27:
  11.  Appeal 25th November, 2011: Police Fraud & Disability Discrimination by Magistrate Paul Kluck, District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien, & CDPP's Shane Hunter:
  12.  Outline of Argument & Submission asAt 31st October, 2011 Appeal Qld Police Fraud & Disability Discrimination by Magistrate Paul Kluck, District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien, & CDPP Shane Hunter:
  13. Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Lies & Dishonesty in Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB:
  14. My Response to Lies & Dishonesty in Respondent's CDPP's Shane Hunter's Outline of Argument for CA201/2011 Qld Court of Appeal re Qld police Fraud & Disability Discrimination: Magistrate Paul Kluck; District Court Judge Kerry John O'Brien KJOB:
  15. Transcript of My Oral Submission on the day, 25th November, 2011, in Qld Court of Appeal, against Qld police corrupt charges to coverup Qld Government Armed Robbery of disabled citizen, before Magistate Paul M Kluck:
  16. Court of Appeal Short Hearing 25th November, 2011; Reserved Decision; Possible Way Forward - Conclusive Evidence: Armed Robbery; International Scrutiny::
  17. Decision: 13th December, 2011 [James S Douglas & Margaret White], Court of Appeal division of Supreme Court of Queensland Mathews v Commissioner of Police [2011] QCA 368 CA No 201 of 2011: :
  18. My Future Actions, after the 13/12/11 Refusal by Qld Court of Appeal of my Appeal::
  19. My request to the Qld Attorney-General to Honour His Duty to Apply to the Court to Set Aside The Miscarriage of Justice, Vexatious Litigant Order:
  20. Decision 12th August,2005: Justice Margaret White Order Remove To Conceal Fraud By Brisbane City Council & Qld Government BS4337_2005_QSC05-222Mathews_v_Morgan_Ors:
  21. Is Justice Margaret White Using Her Judicial Immunity To REPEATEDLY_Conceal Crime By Her Favoured University Of Queensland to StealHome Of Disabled Old Man?:
  22. The Decision of Glory of the Queensland Court of Appeal:
  23. Transcript: 20050601 Magistrates Court Transcript Fraud by Magistrate Walter Harvey Ehrich, [aka Magistrate Topsy Turvey, al la Queensland Court of Appeal], John Peden, Ms Prasley & Police Sergeant Terence G IND:
  24. Transcript: 20081217 Magistrates Court Transcript of Fraud & Farce byMagistrate Walter Harvey Ehrich & Police Sgt Cox:
  25. Index: Queensland's Court of Appeal: ON TRIAL!!
  26. CORRUPT GOVERNMENT Judge Henry George Fryberg protects CORRUPT GOVERNMENT ARMED ROBBERS:
  27. Earlier Mentions of Henry George Fryberg: the former article explains a little extra:


See **** The EVIDENCE **** that ex-police cop parasite Peter Dutton, Liberal Party Federal MP for Dickson, tried, but failed, to close down our website disclosing labor ELECTORAL FRAUD, using corrupt Qld cops.

  Australian Federal Court Judge Jeffrey Spender is criminal scum. See the EVIDENCE

BREAKTHROUGH in Daniel Morcombe case.
We
SCOOPED Channel 7, TV & EXPOSED POLICE CORRUPTION.

See the photo PROOF
 E-Contact us to tell us what you think:

This website is part of the web-presence of

Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA

View list of SOME of my WEBSITES and Bulletin Boards

Email: http://HaigReport.com/eml.html

SEE WHAT I PLAN TO DO ABOUT IT!

Image

CLICK on image => My Election HOMEPAGE


Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA

View list of my WEBSITES and Bulletin Boards

Email: http://HaigReport.com/eml.html

See our LATEST TOPICS:

HOT NEWS: HARD EVIDENCE:  Joe Hockey & FASCIST CRIMINAL congress

I have been bullied my whole life.  See the reason.  That means that I have had fights my whole life.  You can realize the I detest bullies; that is, bullies that are personal to me, politically domestically which includes corrupt polticians, judges and ,MAGISTRATES  & MAGISTRATESmagistrates, more magistrates, lawyers, lawyers, and police, police, and other public sector parasites, plus, politically INTERNATIONALLY.

20041129 more reduced and cropped photo police Rantala.jpgDCP_0517_Big_Big_Big_A_Constable_Antony.jpg

















 CORRUPT ARMED ROBBER [with violence] Henri Elias Rantala. 

[see NEW Website on Henri Rantala]  

"PPheeeeew , that is HUUUUGE", he whispered.

Monica Antony [BigA for Antony]

Corrupt Cops  [talk about being the BUTT of humour]   'Does Swine flu [flew] have anything to do with the POLICE AIR WING? '  and who said, 'PIGS WILL FLY'.

SEE WHAT I PLAN TO DO ABOUT IT!

My Qualifications

       Bachelor of Commerce [BCom] [The University of Queensland] - 1978
       Bachelor of Science [BSc] [The University of Queensland]
- 1997
       Bachelor of Laws [LLB]
[The University of Queensland] - 2003
       Bachelor of Arts [BA]
[The University of Queensland] - 2003


   Police Constable Henri Elias Rantala aka 'Minge'  aka 'Dummy'  
20041129 more reduced and
            cropped photo police Rantala.jpg About this parasite , Corrupt cop Henri Elias Rantala aka Minge, aka dummy [he dumped his superior Superintendent Dale Pointon right into the CORRUPTION QUAGMIRE], Qld police prosecutor now prosecuting exclusively traffic charges, [I hear],, now groomed to perpetuate corruption in the Queensland police and Queensland government.
Rantala is a rare case within the Queensland Police Service [QPS] in that he he was "groomed" and "fast tracked" to continue the fraud, corruption and bribery that is the QPS within the wholesale corruption that is the Queensland labor Government.  [One major way to reduce this is the restoration of the Upper House  to the Queensland Parliament, the Legislative Council, as a democratically elected house.  It was abolished by the Queensland labor government in 1922.]  Rantala was groomed to be a police prosecutor, which is one position where police can be particularly corrupt.  As Prosecutors, they had Advocates Immunity.  I have been able to have this parasite under oath in the witness box subject to my cross examination.   In his evidence in chief at "Call Henri Elias Rantala" he produced a litany of lies.   My cross examination of him, and his replies thereto, at My Cross-Examination Of Corrupt Police Parasite Henri Elias Rantala,  are most instructive.  Considering all the subsequent events in the attempted corrupt cover-up of this gross crime of Armed Robbery by the Queensland Government, the extended period of planning activity that went into the perpetration of this Armed Robbery, and the fact that Rantala Left Indooroopilly Station from which he launched this Armed Robbery, targeting me, soon after in January2005, it appears Rantala was in integral part of this armed Robbery targeting me.  Just a few days prior, Douglas Porter, the then Registrar of The University of Queensland, for whom, as its Rep, Porter was orchestrating this Armed Robbery as a step towards stealing my beneficial ownership of my home, house and land, caused an attack on me and then called the police to me, and Rantala appeared..

 I will build in this caption here, the detail that is relevant to this despicable life form.  This caption will accompany the image of Henri Elias Rantala where ever it appears on our websites.  It will be progressively added to all previous representations of his photo.
We will build into this caption here, the detail that is relevant to this parasite .  Whereever this photo appears on new pages on our websites, this caption will accompany the image of Corrupt cop Henri Elias Rantala aka Minge, aka dummy [he dumped his superior Superintendent Dale Pointon right into the CORRUPTION QUAGMIRE], Qld police prosecutor now prosecuting exclusively traffic charges, [I hear],, groomed to perpetuate corruption in the Queensland police and Queensland government.   This caption will be progressively added to all previous representations of the photo of Corrupt cop Henri Elias Rantala aka Minge, aka dummy [he dumped his superior Superintendent Dale Pointon right into the CORRUPTION QUAGMIRE], Qld police prosecutor now prosecuting exclusively traffic charges, [I hear],, groomed to perpetuate corruption in the Queensland police and Queensland government. 



   Police Constable Monica Louise Antony aka 'Big A for Antony' 

DCP_0517-Big_Big Big A
            Constable Antony.jpg
We will build into this caption here, the detail that is relevant to this twit brainwashed with a bidet .  Whereever this photo appears on new pages on our websites, this caption will accompany the image of Corrupt cop Monica Louise Antony aka BigA for Antony, SUPER DUMB FEMALE Just consider her answers in my cross-examination of her, now that the police hierarchy has shuffled her out of the way, so she can do no harm to police corruption by her inability to lie convincingly.   This caption will be progressively added to all previous representations of the photo of Corrupt cop Monica Louise Antony aka BigA for Antony, SUPER DUMB FEMALE Just consider her answers in my cross-examination of her, now that the police hierarchy has shuffled her out of the way, so she can do no harm to police corruption by her inability to lie convincingly. 


../CorruptMagistratesMenu.php ../Corrupt Police& Magistrates Menu.php An example of a CASCADING Drop Down Menu.

MENU: Rantala-Gate: Corrupt Police & Magistrates Mafia.

CDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.php

Dumb Cop Henri Rantala UPDATE:


SEE:    Rantala-Gate:  => Qld Police CORRUPTION COVER-UP
& FACE of    Rantala-Gate:

UPDATE:

More PROOF of SENIOR LEVEL POLICE Corruption in Qld

[and not just in Queensland:]
Dumb cop Henri Elias Rantala dumps Superintendent Pointon and Senior cops right into the CORRUPTION MIRE that is Queensland.



"The offensive material has been subsequently been maintained on the internet since that time until the present day.  I have been contacted by Superintendent Pointon, Officers from Ethical Standards Command, Security Intelligence Branch, State Crime Operations Command, relatives all asking question about the material from 2006 until the present day."

"The offensive material has been subsequently been maintained on the internet since that time until the present day.  I have been contacted by Superintendent Pointon, Officers from Ethical Standards Command, Security Intelligence Branch, State Crime Operations Command, relatives all asking questions about the material from 2006 until the present day."

../CorruptMagistratesMenu.php ../Corrupt Police& Magistrates Menu.php An example of a CASCADING Drop Down Menu.

MENU: Rantala-Gate: Corrupt Police & Magistrates Mafia.

CDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.php
This, above, has been stated in writing in a signed statement by the
Corrupt Police Prosecutor Henri Elias Rantala, dated 21st October, 2009; [20091021].   What he calls "offensive material" is the irrefutable PROOF that Police Officer Henri Elias Rantala, committed an ARMED ROBBERY.  This "offensive material" also includes MY REPORT TO POLICE OF ARMED ROBBERY, which they have ignored.  This statement by Rantala, is now PROOF that the police are AWARE OF THE ARMED ROBBERY and are ignoring my complaint of ARMED ROBBERY, AND BREAKING, ENTERING AND STEALING by Queensland Police and Government officials.   I am trained in law with an LLB apart from my other qualifications.  I know more law that these mug police officers.  The evidence, the  irrefutable PROOF,  is shown on these websites.  It shows that Rantala, while armed, ensured that thieves could ransack my home.  The fact that the thieves pretended they were from Brisbane City  Council is irrelevant, as they did not have a legal right to enter.  The Queensland Parliament sets the process for Council to enter private property.  This involved obtaining a COURT ORDER.  The armed robbers and thieves did not have a court order.  Australia is becoming a REAL POLICE STATE, when police believe they can over-ride STATUTE LAW passed by the legislature.  

That police ignore instances of ARMED ROBBERY, is not unique in Queensland.   Andrew Phillip Scipione the Commissioner of the New South Wales Police Force is GUILTY OF SIMILAR CRIME [cover-up] IN NSW as relates to the case below.



Thieves using ARMED POLICE to detain the owner of the property, and keep the owner of the property separated from his property while the thieves steal the property, happens regularly with Queensland Corrupt Police.   One case occurred on 15th September, 2005 in Cairns when the thieves from St Vincent de Paul Society, with whom Jim Tierney previously of JT's Gym in NSW, were operating a Joint Venture for Charitable Purposes, called "Vinnie's Gym", where Jim Tierney supplied his own labour and his own Gym equipment, valued many years previous, at over $1 million dollars worth.  The thieves from St Vincent de Paul Society had corrupt ARMED police attend and 'escort' Jim Tierney, AT GUN POINT, from his equipment and keep him from it, while they stripped the Gym of Jim Tierney's valuable gym equipment.

On 15th September, 2005,the ARMED police and sparmy callous hypocritical Brisbane based paid staff of St Vincent dePaul Society, arrived unannounced to steal Jim Tierney's one million dollars plus worth of gym equipment, by ostensibly 'closing' the gym. When one of the instructors asked what they should tell the group of very disabled people who were due in that afternoon, the answer from the sparmy hypocritical CEO of the thieving St Vincent dePaul Society was 'life is tough'. In an effort to calm the situation, "Enough," said Judith Tierney.


Police Armed Robbery Elsewhere

This has been a case of POLICE THUGGERY.  This, my case, is not a unique case of armed police using their position, to detain property owners, to enable thieves to rob them. Another documented case occurred in 2002 at Queanbeyan, with ARMED ROBBER scum pig Leslie Charles Gilroy  employed by Andrew Phillip Scipione the Commissioner of the New South Wales Police Force



../CorruptMagistratesMenu.php ../Corrupt Police& Magistrates Menu.php An example of a CASCADING Drop Down Menu.

MENU: Rantala-Gate: Corrupt Police & Magistrates Mafia.

CDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.phpCDDM_StartMenu160.php


  Directory re


 Tax & Investment Planning Services - 1982 to 1989
 [TIPS] [Townsville]


TIPS for TAX logo
 
T
ax & Investment Planning Services


About our first TIPS office in Townsville at 62-66 Railway Avenue, Townsville.
 
About our second TIPS office at 56 - 58 Thuringowa Drive, KIRWAN, Townsville.

    UPDATES:
 These updates will be dated, [what else, but], and be in order with the latest at the top.

[20081231]
Favicon.ico links to Website Index pages:
  [Just click on any logo/favicon to be taken to that particular Web-site.]

  Image             FISH        us  uk  nz Au  Ca   In                       



Our LATEST TOPICS:

    Listed here  20090804_0947GMT
       http://CorruptJudgeBrendanButlerChiefMagistrateCaucusingPoliceFraudAim.info

         http://CorruptJudgeMarshallIrwinChiefMagistrateCaucusingPoliceFraudAim.info

        
http://IndiaStudentAustraliaVisaPRScamShonkRipOffRaceFraudPrisonDeport.info
     

    Listed here  20090724_1103GMT

          http://DangerousLiaisonCapriCorruptQueenslandPoliceArmedHoldUpFraudCMC.info

          http://FlowerHartMichaelMeadowsFraudWCOWhiteIndustriesCaboolturePark.info

      
   http://CrimeMafiaPoliceProsecutorHenriRantalaMagistrateEhrichStrofield.info

    Listed here  20090712
       http://WalterHarveyEhrichCorruptMagistratePoliceFraudArmedRobberyTheft.info

         http://ColinJStrofieldCorruptMagistratePoliceFraudArmedRobberyTheftQld.info

       http://StVincentDePaulFraudBullyingPeterMaherJerryMcAuliffeMareeFell.info

    Listed here  20090601

Australian Public Sector CLICK HERE  Anti-Corruption Conference 2009

 CLICK HERE - Home of Fraud, Rort & Sin
 & sponsored by the corrupt partnership of the corrupt partners of Qld's CMC,  NSW's ICAC & WA's CCC.

 Allstralian Parliament
Member for TARDIS CLICK HERE
CLICK HERE  Russell Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA



    Listed here  20090525

Daniel Morcombe  Photo Evidence Update:

Police GAG Witness &
Police threaten Witness 

http://DanielMorcombePhotoEvidenceUpdatePoliceGagThreatenWitness.info

Beware of
CRIME STOPPERS

 
It Assists Corrupt Police, Political Crime & Criminal Fraud

  http://BewareCrimeStoppersAssistCorruptPolicePoliticCrimeCriminalFraud.info

  It Assists Corrupt Police, Political Crime & Criminal Fraud

    Listed here  20090520

    HOT NEWS: HARD EVIDENCE:  Joe Hockey & FASCIST CRIMINAL congress

    Joe Hockey & NSW Liberals Supports Lisa Chikarovski's

        Sewer Language Internet Bullying & INCITING MURDER

       This sewer mouth espousing slut language Lisa Chikarovski  espousing the slut language does great harm to Joe Hockey.

    Listed here 20090509:

TIPS for TAX logo
Tax & Investment Planning Services

  1.   *     Analysis of the 21st Century World Recession-Global Financial Economic Crisis
  2.   *   Free Advice How to SURVIVE 21st Century World Recession & PROSPER
  3.   *     Free Advice How to FIND a JOB & MAKE MONEY finding It
  4.   *     Free Small Business Advisory Service
  5.  *      Free T.I.P.S. for Tax & Investment Planning Service
  6.  *      FREE study Learn How To Do Own Personal Financial Planning Advice

   
    Listed here 20090503:




linksforumworldrecession
Links to our FORUMS regarding the 21st Century World Recession, SURVIVING IT & PROSPERING.
  1. 21st Century World Recession
  2. Analysis of the 21st Century World Recession
  3. FULL detail of the Analysis of 21st Century World Recession
  4. How to SURVIVE the 21st Century World Recession, & PROSPER
  5. In detail: How to SURVIVE the 21st Century World Recession, & PROSPER.
  6. Looking for Work: Looking for a Job:
  7. How to FIND A JOB, & MAKE MONEY doing it!!
  8. FULL detail: How to FIND A JOB, & MAKE MONEY doing it!!
  9. FULL detail: How to FIND A JOB, & MAKE MONEY FINDING it, and REAL MONEY doing it!!
  10. FULL DETAIL: Looking for Work: Looking for a Job:
  11. Small Business Advisory FORUM
  12. Full Description, Small Business Advisory Forum.
I have addressed this way forward, depending upon one's predilection, based on one's past actions or inclinations: Income from working for an 'employer' or working in one's own business.

  1. Looking for Work: Looking for a Job: How to FIND A JOB, & MAKE MONEY doing it!!
  2. Small Business Advisory FORUM
HaigReport Themes

Themes of  Websites
for the
HAIG   REPORT: Group of Websites:
[We expect, in time, to have all of the thousands of pages on the
HAIG   REPORT: group of websites accessible from this Menu of THEMES. Eventually, there will be 20 themes, each with an average of 15 to 20 websites/domains/directories, with each website/domain having an average of 20 pages. This would equate to 20 x (15 to 20) x 20 = 6,000 to 8,000 pages. This menu of Themes will be included near the bottom of each page, in time. With one line of code, strategically placed, this Menu of Themes is now on thousands of pages. We are continually and progressively adding pages to this Menu of Themes of website Menus.]

commonheader.php

Reg. Office: 254 Hawken Drive, St Lucia, Qld. 4067, Australia.  
Editor-in-Chief:  Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA      EMAIL us anytime:  Please Please make a donation using BPay.  using  Please make a donation using BPay. 

Menu: HaigReport'sThemes or Categories of the the Topics of the HaigReport Group of Websites: 
© COPYRIGHT: Russell Gordon Haig Mathews 2002 - 2018

The LATEST ADDITIONS are added to the top:


See  All 67 Domain Names in the HaigReport Group 

© COPYRIGHT: Russell Gordon Haig Mathews 2002 - 2018

Now here are the THEMES:



  1. Commonwealth of Australia Knowingly Employs LIARS, CHEATS and CRIMINALS:


  2. Government Corruption Infecting Corporates; ASX:


  3. New ADDITIONAL platform; Printed Distributed HaigReport NEWSPAPER:


  4. Self Help Law: Do your own Legals/Law:


  5. International: Corrupt Politics & Corrupt religion:


  6. About HaigReport Group of Websites including
    Vote One Russell Mathews:


  7. Russell Mathews [BCom BSc LLB & BA] Commentary additional to the rest of these Websites:


  8. Legal Rights, & BLACKLISTS of parasite residents & tenants in rental accommodation:


  9. RAMPANT POLICE CORRUPTION Exposed by HaigReport Websites; Publicize Your Complaint Here:


  10. Other public sector corruption Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  11. RELIGION Corruption CRIME & PAEDOPHILIA Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  12. Qld Govt Translink wankers & pony spankers Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  13. Corrupt JUDGES, COURTS, & TRIBUNALS Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  14. Corrupt LAWYERS Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  15. Corrupt POLITICANS Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  16. University of Qld Fraud & Corruption Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  17. Corruption at other universities; Exposed by HaigReport Websites:


  18. Expose' of Other CORRUPTION, including TELSTRA, under influence of public sector parasites, as exposed by the HaigReport Group of Websites:


  19. Business Promoted by HaigReport Websites:


  20. Finance by HaigReport Websites:

This page is part of the Internet presence of

Russell G H Mathews BCom BSc LLB BA
View list of SOME of my WEBSITES and Bulletin Boards

Email: http://HaigReport.com/eml.html


SEE WHAT I PLAN TO DO ABOUT IT!


Image
CLICK on image => My Election HOMEPAGE